magia Spontaneous Domains + Holy Warrior

[horace]

Ciao a tutti!

Ho una domanda regolistica per voi: se prendo il talento Spontaneus Domain (Complete Champions):

SPONTANEOUS DOMAINS

You need not prepare your domain spells in advance.

Prerequisites: Ability to cast 3rd-level spells, access to two or more cleric domains.

Benefit: When preparing your spells for the day, you can leave your domain slots open. You can then choose, when the situation arises, to cast any of the domain spells you could normally have prepared for a given level. However, you are still limited to one domain spell per level per day.

ed il talento Holy Warrior (sempre CC):

HOLY WARRIOR [RESERVE]

Your zeal on the battlefield allows you to deal extra damage in combat.

Prerequisites: Ability to cast 4th-level spells, access to the War domain.

Benefit: As long as you have a 4th-level or higher War domain spell available to cast, you gain a bonus on your weapon damage rolls equal to the level of the highest-level War spell you have available to cast.

As a secondary benefit, you gain a +1 competence bonus to your caster level when casting force spells.

con domini Forza e Guerra, posso considerare tutti gli slot di dominio non utilizzati utili per il bonus di Holy Warrior? Secondo voi un'accoppiata di talenti per un bonus del genere è sprecata? Per il mio chierico pensavo ad un'evoluzione del tipo:

3: Divine ward (PH2)

6: Spontanues Domain

9: Holy Warrior

12: Incantesimi rapidi

15: Metamagia divina inc rapidi

18: Scacciare extra

Grazie a tutti quelli che risponderanno!

[thondar]

si

How does a reserve feat (CM) work with spontaneous casters since they could have a fireball as a known 3rd-level spell but they might use that spell slot for a different spell?

As long as the spontaneous caster knows an appropriate spell and has at least one unused spell slot of that spell’s level or higher, he gains the full benefit of the reserve feat. A sorcerer with the Fiery Burst feat who knows fireball can use its primary benefit as long as he has at least one unused spell slot of 3rd level or higher.

[Alexander Loch]

Mi accodo al thread e chiedo: se il chierico in questione fosse un Ordained Champion...i benefici di Holy Warrior li otterrebbe solo per il fatto di avere incantesimi in memoria disponibili per essere convertiti in incantesimi di dominio?

[thondar]

Mi accodo al thread e chiedo: se il chierico in questione fosse un Ordained Champion...i benefici di Holy Warrior li otterrebbe solo per il fatto di avere incantesimi in memoria disponibili per essere convertiti in incantesimi di dominio?

no

Does the ability to spontaneously cast domain spells granted by the Domain Spontaneity feat (CD) fulfill the spell requirement of the reserve feats from CM?

Not technically. Since you don’t have a list of spells known, only a list of spells prepared and the ability to cast some spells spontaneously, having the ability to spontaneously cast domain spells that fulfill the requirements for reserve feats does not fulfill the reserve feat requirements.

That said, there’s probably no harm in allowing it, and an unflinching DM confident in his ability to challenge you at every turn can have no problem hand-waving the technicality away.

[horace]

Ma secondo voi valgono la pena due talenti per il bonus di Holy Warrior?

[Alexander Loch]

Se ti interessa solo Holy Warrior, magari prendi solo quello. Ti scegli un incantesimo di dominio che da tenere sempre memorizzato per avere il bonus... e gli altri li usi come vuoi.